Aged Act review needed
Ombudsman report exposes flaws in aged care assessment system and calls for a review of the new Aged Care Act.

The Commonwealth Ombudsman has raised serious concerns about the way older Australians are assessed for government-funded aged care.
It found that the Department of Health, Disability and Ageing’s administration of the Single Assessment System (SAS), including the Integrated Assessment Tool (IAT), has been unreasonable. The ombudsman also concluded that a reasonable person would lack confidence that the system is fair and consistent.
The report, Automation and Oversight in Aged Care: Flaws in the Design and Operation of the Single Assessment System (October 2026), examined the Integrated Assessment Tool (IAT) and the Department’s oversight of assessment providers.
The IAT uses algorithms to determine whether an older person is eligible for the Commonwealth Home Support Program (CHSP) or Support at Home (SaH), and for SaH, their funding classification and priority category.
A separate human decision maker approves access to recommended services, but cannot simply override the automated classification or priority outcome because it appears clinically inappropriate.
The investigation was prompted by widespread concerns about the system, including long wait times, inconsistent assessments, a lack of transparency in decision-making, and reports that the tool can diminish the role of professional judgement.
What did it find?
The Ombudsman’s report identified inadequate scrutiny of assessment provider performance, deficiencies in assessor training assurance, poor complaints oversight, and a failure to undertake meaningful risk assessment before implementing binding automated decisions.
The report also recorded clinical concerns that the algorithm could under-identity frailty, functional vulnerability and clinical complexity. Importantly, the Ombudsman did not clinically validate the algorithm or establish that it systematically produces inappropriate care outcomes.
Rather, flaws in its design and oversight raise serious questions about its reliability and justify independent clinical review.
One case highlighted by the Ombudsman involved a woman with a rapidly progressive neurological condition who was approved for a high level of support but given a standard priority rating, with an estimated wait of 10 to 11 months at the time of the complaint, despite her urgent circumstances.
The report notes that indicative standard priority waiting times had subsequently fallen to seven to eight months, although actual access depends on local service availability.
Key recommendations
The Ombudsman made 10 recommendations. Recommendations 1 and 2 call for legislative and regulatory changes allowing assessment delegates to substitute a human decision for an automated IAT outcome in appropriate circumstances, supported by clear guidance.
Recommendation 3, which separately calls for a comprehensive review of the Aged Care Act 2024 and Aged Care Rules to identify and correct legal defects, inconsistencies and unintended consequences.
Other recommendations address public transparency, consultation, assessment provider oversight, complaints, the algorithm’s business rules, and external audit.
The findings are particularly significant because they reinforce concerns advocacy organisations raised since the development of the new aged care framework.
Aged Care Act a work in progress
In May 2026, National Seniors Australia (NSA) welcomed government changes designed to improve aged care but noted that ongoing reform would be necessary.
We pointed to our October 2024 submission on the Aged Care Bill 2024, where it was warned that "we won't get the new aged care system right the first time" and argued that continuous review and refinement of both the legislation and the rules underpinning it will be required.
The Ombudsman's findings support that position. They demonstrate why implementation must be accompanied by transparent decision making, effective safeguards, rigorous monitoring and a willingness to correct problems as they emerge.
For older people, a theoretically consistent assessment is of little comfort if it does not accurately reflect their circumstances or if they cannot understand and challenge the outcome.
NSA has consistently advocated for stronger assessment integrity, reduced waiting times, and an end to rationing of access to care so older Australians receive support based on their needs rather than system constraints.
The report also comes amid stakeholder concerns that assessment may restrict access to a higher level of care. However, the Ombudsman did not find that the algorithm was designed to contain government expenditure or determine whether it systematically under-assesses needs.
The confirmed concerns lie in the opacity of decisions, weak governance and insufficient safeguards for people whose circumstances are not adequately captured.
Government response
The Department accepted Recommendation 3 and several other recommendations, while noting Recommendations 1 and 2, which are directed to government, and describing its proposed escalation pathway as a different approach to human review. It would therefore be misleading to say that all 10 recommendations were accepted without qualification.
On 15 October 2026, Minister for Aged Care and Seniors, Sam Rae, announced an independent, clinically informed review of Support at Home classification and prioritisation mechanisms. The review is expected to report in the first half of 2027, with its findings published in full and tabled in Parliament.
The Government has also announced an escalation pathway intended to operate from January 2027, allowing exceptional cases to be referred for human consideration and potential adjustment of Support at Home classification or priority.
Unlike the Ombudsman’s preferred approach of empowering assessment delegates to substitute their decisions, the announced pathway gives the Department, through the System Governor or a delegate, the power to change outcomes. Its accessibility, timeliness, and practical operation will require close scrutiny.
The Ombudsman acknowledged improvements include shorter indicative priority wait times and the Department’s October 2026 publication of additional algorithm information. However, the report cautioned that it remains unclear whether the material is detailed enough for independent verification of assessment outcomes.
For NSA, the priority is clear: older Australians must have assessment decisions that are fair, clinically informed, understandable and open to review.
The independent review and escalation pathway are welcome steps, but meaningful reform will depend on implementation, transparency and whether the changes improve real-world access to appropriate care.
Technology should support professional judgement, not displace it. No older Australian should be left without timely, suitable care because an automated decision fails to reflect their needs and there is no practical way to correct it.
Clarification needed
NSA acknowledges the government's recent legislative amendments, commitment to independent review, and steps toward greater transparency in the Single Assessment System.
However, these measures should be distinguished from full implementation of the Commonwealth Ombudsman's recommendations.
In particular, the new escalation pathway does not provide the same direct clinical override mechanism recommended by the Ombudsman.
Further clarification is needed on which recommendations the government considers acquitted, the evidence supporting that assessment and the timeframe for implementing outstanding safeguards.
The critical measure will be whether appropriately qualified professionals can ensure older Australians receive clinically appropriate care without unnecessary delays or additional administrative barriers.
*The discount applies to the total National Seniors travel insurance premium and is for National Seniors Australia members only. Discounts do not apply to the rate of GST and stamp duty or any changes you make to the policy. AGA has the discretion to withdraw or amend this discount offer at any time. This discount cannot be used in conjunction with any other promotional offer or discount.
National Seniors Australia Ltd ABN 89 050 523 003, AR 282736, is an authorised representative of AWP Australia Pty Ltd, ABN 52 097 227 177, AFSL 245631, trading as Allianz Global Assistance (AGA), and acts as AGA's agent and not as your agent. nib Travel Services (Australia) Pty Ltd (nib), ABN 81 115 932 173, AFSL 308461 acts as third party administrator on behalf of AGA, managing claims, complaints, enquiries and sales. This is general advice only. Before you buy, you should consider whether the product is appropriate for you, the Product Disclosure Statement (PDS), Financial Services Guide (FSG) and Target Market Determination (TMD) is available from us. This insurance is underwritten by Pacific International Insurance Pty Ltd, ABN 83 169 311 193, AFSL 523921.















